The Winners Write History.
Guest post by AI philosopher Niklas Gerholm. From the age of the camera to that of the blockchain: when photographic evidence became commonplace, the writing of history was democratized — but when anyone can write history, anything can be written. Therefore, the question of who stands behind the words becomes more important than ever.
That is what we have said. That is how it is. Because those who wrote history are also the ones who passed the information on from the event to our time. But if you think about it — is that history really the history that unfolded, or is it shaped by those who wrote it — that is, those who actually created the history we take part in?
There is of course evidence for much of history. Archaeologists and historians work constantly to verify facts, but it is also difficult to substantiate something that happened a thousand years ago — or perhaps just 500 years ago.
Was there room for the subdued, the defeated, the oppressed to describe their history? Or was it written by the winners? Is the story of the oppressed instead written by people who interpreted something that occurred, but about which they cannot be one hundred percent certain because these voices were never allowed to speak?
The Age of the Camera
It is in the age of the camera that we begin to be able to gather photographic evidence. One of the clearest historical events, and perhaps one of the most documented, is the Second World War. Who has not seen the black-and-white aerial photographs of the Auschwitz concentration camp, or the Jewish man whose beard is held up by a German soldier with a sneer? Or the picture of the Jewish boy being threatened by a German soldier in one of the many ghettos that existed?
We do not have those pictures from Egypt's slaves or the executions of the French Revolution. We have the words, but not the same photographic evidence of what happened before. Images could of course be manipulated in the past as well, but AI has made it possible to do so in an entirely different way and on a completely different scale. And it is during the 20th century that we also get the moving image broadcast into our TV screens. Would we really have known what was going on in Vietnam had television not existed? Perhaps — but would we have known it to the extent that drove young people into the streets in massive protests? And would Hitler have achieved the same success if we humans had seen more of him in moving pictures, instead of only being able to hear his voice on the radio?
The winners wrote history.
But as images began to become commonplace in a society that moved from sheer day-to-day survival toward being able to treat oneself, live, and engage in things other than toiling for the state or a magnate, we were now able, with new technology, to take the power to create history away from the winners and instead take part in shaping it.
That is the democratization of the writing of history.
Who is Behind the Story?
But the question arises — what does it mean to take part in shaping history? What responsibility? Which perspectives should be adopted, and which can be considered to carry the truth?
Does it mean that all voices receive the same opportunity to become part of history? Of course not. Even in a digital society, disparities exist in power, resources, and access to the systems that make information visible and lasting. Being able to verify who said something does not mean all voices receive equal space, but it at least makes it clearer who stands behind the story.
And the more people who can take part in writing history, the more important the question becomes of who actually stands behind what we read.
As I study the information carriers of digitalism, I become increasingly convinced that those working to make digital information verifiable are now on the verge of taking on an increasingly vital role on a new stage. By placing a claim on the blockchain, you guarantee that this claim was made and that it was I who claimed that this is how it happened. It is yet another way to use crypto to create stable documentation of a claim and try to give people the opportunity, if not to obtain the truth, at least to provide the means to arrive at their own perspectives with stable sources.
In an article (https://www.witnis.se/en/blog/what-is-verifiable-communication) by Matthew Davis at Witnis, who works with verifiable communication, he reflects on questions such as who has the authority to speak, whose story becomes part of the historical record, and, ultimately, whom or what we choose to trust.
By placing sender, authority, and message on the blockchain, these three elements are solidified, giving the recipient something tangible to hold onto when it comes to authenticity. As we have previously stated, this is a luxury in a society where such things are under constant threat from the wide-open AI landscape.
So the winners no longer write history. We all do. But when everyone can write it, anything can be written as well. The blockchain does not prevent anything from being written, but it can make it clearer who stands behind the words and whether what was published has been altered. That is where machine and human meet the way they are meant to meet. That is what Witnis does.
Niklas Gerholm
Guest contributorGästskribent — AI-filosof, författare till Syntopism.com
Niklas Gerholm är AI-filosof och författare bakom Syntopism.com, där han utvecklar ett ramverk för kommunikationsparadigm, bildning och approximativ sanning. Han skriver som extern gästskribent; åsikterna i texten är hans egna och representerar inte nödvändigtvis Witnis.