Truth, Trust, Witnis
Guest post by AI philosopher Niklas Gerholm. From the herds of the savannah to the information flows of digitalism: why trust is the load-bearing construction of civilization, why objective truth is out of reach — and what role verifiable communication can play when approximate truths are the best we have.
If trust collapses, the whole of civilization collapses — because if we cannot trust each other, we cannot live with each other either.
When early humans roamed the savannah, they were exposed to countless dangers. To handle these dangers, they had to be able to rely on their own knowledge and on the other members of the tribe. If one couldn't do that, one risked perishing. But if the group developed confidence in their own knowledge and in each other, they became not only skilled survivors against the hazards, but also against other tribes. Their mutual confidence is what we call trust.
Trust was naturally immensely important for survival 200,000 years ago, but it is just as vital today. However, we have a problem that the people of yesterday did not face to the same extent: in our time, technology exists that makes it incomprehensibly easy to create credible lies to manipulate information — and, by extension, human beings.
We live in an era known as digitalism, today practically synonymous with the internet. In my texts on syntopism, I speak of four communication paradigms: speech, writing, the printing press, and the internet. All of these paradigm shifts were sparked by a technology that subsequently gave birth to an idea of expanded freedom. But that idea is always followed by enormous disorder, which is then succeeded by order. Right now, we stand in the midst of the vast mess of the internet paradigm shift.
Capital vs Information
There is a very important marker when it comes to the digital era with the internet as a paradigm shifter. The marker tells us that we are now transitioning from the dominance of capital to the dominance of information. Ever since the advent of barter, capital has fundamentally aimed at a single thing: acquiring power. Once trade has satisfied the first three tiers of the hierarchy of needs once established by psychologist Maslow — survival, safety, and belonging — tier four arrives: power. The purpose of Western capital is, in various ways, to maintain and assert power.
Power can serve both destructive and constructive purposes. Power can, for instance, conquer territory, emotions, or data. Data, however, is information, and with information, you can practically acquire whatever you want. Modern capital aims to procure information. In war, information enables territorial conquests: when you know troop movements or how to engineer the ultimate weapons, you can also neutralize units to seize land. In peacetime, information allows you to buy loyalty, status, and infrastructure. All of this serves to build power. And power is — contrary to what many claim — fundamental to human civilizational and neurological development.
What happens in the internet paradigm is that information is now free and no longer needs to be purchased. The big tech companies have made initial investments to build centers that process the information we entirely voluntarily upload about ourselves and everything we feel. Naturally, data centers are still required to administer this, but compared to what it would cost to extract the same information in the old communication paradigm, where the printing press reigned supreme, it is likely a mere pittance.
This means that information is now beating capital. Capital is no longer as interesting when information is uploaded voluntarily and without payment. But we will still need capital — do not misunderstand me. It is a lubricant in everyday life so that we can acquire things we cannot produce ourselves. But information is now a commodity on a global scale, on par with capital.
Consider this: today, an entire union negotiates with corporations. Not with nations, but with corporations. The EU actually negotiates with tech giants. Name a single time in history when unions have negotiated with companies at the level we do today, where we even regulate and enact laws that fundamentally impact people due to the products of tech companies. Australia banned youths under 16 from holding accounts on certain social media platforms. The EU's Chat Control proposal risks severely infringing upon people's digital privacy.
Disinformation and Lies
What does it mean, then, when information begins to eclipse capital? Naturally, it entails a vast number of things well worth focusing on, not least within philosophy. But here, we concentrate on trust.
Disinformation and lies have always existed. It became particularly apparent during the era of the printing press, when leaflets with disinformation were dropped from the sky onto populations during wars, carrying the message that they should surrender and that a foreign power possessed far greater control than it actually did. False radio broadcasts were also transmitted. Even if it was not printed information, it was a form of mass communication that echoed the printing press model of spreading messages.
It is in the latter phase of the AI and internet era that it becomes exceptionally easy for the average person to forge information. It has never been so simple for people to craft disinformation and lies as it is today. Everyone has access to the technology. It costs next to nothing, and the production of digital artifacts is astonishingly convincing. With that said, we must acknowledge that deceit and disinformation are reaching heights never before witnessed.
Trust and Truth
Trust is the transfer of information from one subject to another. But trust cannot exist without a foundation upon which to rest. I cannot tell you that the sky is blue if you do not know what the color blue is. Therefore, every individual must take responsibility for the knowledge they acquire. And today, it is remarkably easy to read up on any given topic — precisely thanks to the internet with its texts, podcasts, and videos.
The problem is that knowledge in itself does not have to be reliable. That is: it does not have to be true. This implies that we must strive for truth in our knowledge. We are required to judge whether something is true. But on what basis are we to make that assessment? The question then becomes: what is true?
In my philosophical texts, I arrive at the conclusion that there is no objective truth. This troubles a great many people, yet with a fool's persistence, I maintain that it is true that there is nothing that is true. You see, of course, that this is an impossible statement in itself, but I salvage it in my writings by stating that the only thing we can ever know are approximate truths — truths that are as close to an objective truth as possible. It might sound woolly, but we need tools that best help us arrive at approximate truths capable of building trust among us in an age where trust is more fractured than ever. In my work, I argue that we should use empirical inquiry rather than the humanities as our yardstick.
And the fact remains that if trust collapses, the whole of civilization collapses. Because if we cannot trust each other, we cannot live with each other either, and we will be stranded on isolated islands — something humanity has never been able to endure. That is why we need these approximate truths.
Bildung Fosters Responsibility and Judgment
So where do we find these remarkable approximate truths? If we do not start from clear concepts regarding what is approximately true (which requires a great deal of philosophy), we have to begin somewhere else. I just said that knowledge is something we need to discern whether something is approximately true or false. You need to know what the color blue is to accept the proposition that the sky is blue. Or at the very least, you must know what the color blue is not.
This brings us to the idea that we need knowledge. And knowledge is, as everyone knows, information — information about an array of different things relevant to our lives. Today, we choose to outsource parts of that knowledge to our chatbots. We drain our own brains of knowledge, absorbing it only when we need it, just to forget it shortly after. Recently conducted Chinese studies have demonstrated this phenomenon.
This makes us slightly dumber. But outsourcing information is something the brain likes, because it saves energy — and energy was precisely what we had the least of on the savannah. The brain reasons the same way 200,000 years later. It was perfectly fine back then, but it is less ideal in the age of digitalism.
The second effect this has on us is that we rarely verify our knowledge. In the information stream we are subjected to daily, it is difficult to constantly check what is probable and less probable (notice how I avoid the terms true and false). Consequently, we develop a bias, which is entirely human — the brain requires a narrative around which to orient itself.
Yet in a world fraught with disinformation and falsehoods, we can also adopt biases that are not merely fragile, but outright dangerous to ourselves. As more and more people come to believe the same things, it becomes easy to form so-called filter bubbles, a concept discussed heavily during the 2010s. It simply means that we mirror our opinions in others because we seek belonging. That, too, is one of the brain's desires. Belonging gives us a sense of security and safety that traces its lineage from our days on the savannah straight into the present.
This forms what we call narratives in human beings. And these are immensely important to us in our lives. Moreover, they become harder to dismantle as we grow older. This is something various powers naturally understand and exploit. When disinformation becomes so easy to spread, it acts as a very useful instrument for such powers. By powers, I do not necessarily mean foreign adversaries, but also politicians, media outlets, and academia. Note that this does not necessarily mean there is an intent to spread ideas to produce a false worldview. Instead, the body politic is influenced by cultures and ideas carried forward through institutions across decades. These, however, can be more or less anchored in reality.
As long as these ideas belong purely to the humanities, this represents a crucial intersection you must keep in mind. Everything stated within the humanities that claims to be true must be situated within a context.
Certain actions that in Swedish culture are seen as undeniably reprehensible and unlawful may, in other cultural environments and under specific circumstances, be perceived as legitimate or right. This can depend on how religious, social, or cultural norms are interpreted within that given context. It is thus true for them in the sense that the action fits into the worldview and normative framework prevailing there. In a secular state where the same action is prohibited by law, it is instead judged as wrongful and punishable. An action can therefore be perceived as right in one context, but wrong and criminal in another.
What one experiences as true is always relative to a context, whereas empirical data such as gravity almost always yields the same outcome regardless of context — at least on Earth. And that makes our globalized world immensely complex. In an increasingly global world where more cultures integrate with one another, contexts have begun to clash. Naturally, this creates friction, and it makes perceived truth profoundly important. What is it that we hold to be true, and what is actually true?
What Is True?
We just mentioned knowledge as a means of approaching truth. But that is not enough. Not by a long shot. In a world as dangerous as it was on the savannah, and as it is today, humans must learn to assume responsibility and not abdicate it to something else, such as the state or a fellow human being. The responsibility is always yours. That means you must ask yourself how you take responsibility. Responsibility is what is exercised in the act of judgment. But responsibility stems from bildung. Bildung is best explained through the German bildung tradition. It differs from mere education or vocational training, which is crucial to note: training asks what you know — bildung asks who you become through what you learn.
The Bildung Tradition
The bildung tradition is a European ideal of self-cultivation with deep roots in the German Enlightenment and Romanticism, particularly in the work of thinkers like Wilhelm von Humboldt. Bildung translates roughly to self-formation: the long-term cultivation of the human being through knowledge, experience, reflection, and exposure to different perspectives. The objective is therefore not primarily vocational competence or data gathering, but the development of an autonomous individual equipped with sound judgment.
Central to this is that the individual is confronted with that which lies beyond herself: history, philosophy, science, art, other people, and foreign ideas. Through this confrontation, she is forced to reconsider her preconceptions. Bildung, therefore, does not mean accumulating the 'correct' opinions, but cultivating the capacity to think, evaluate, and transform one's own thought process.
The tradition also has a societal dimension. A free society requires people who do not merely yield to authority, impulse, or group norms, but are capable of exercising independent judgment. In the age of digitalism, we must carefully reflect on how machines can deliver information and answers. As a result, humanity's focus on simply knowing things diminishes, while the imperative to understand, assess, integrate, and question them grows. In doing so, AI renders the classical ideal of bildung more relevant than ever.
To attain approximate truths without stumbling over massive philosophical hurdles, the key lies in cultivating oneself. This means acquiring knowledge across broad domains, but also synthesizing this knowledge and challenging it with new perspectives:
- You must speak and interact with people who disagree with you, to discover new ideas.
- You must do so with respect.
- You must not do it simply to win an argument.
- If you lose an argument, you gain an insight — and that is worth far more.
- You must do it to test your own theses as rigorously as possible, to see if they truly hold up.
- You must not test your theses within the echo chambers of like-minded peers.
- You must not choose just anyone to stress-test your models. It should be educated, cultivated minds — but from the opposing side.
This demands an enormous amount from you. It requires time, dedication, and energy. But the truth is likely that those who achieve this will fare best in the new era of digitalism.
The Blockchain
Blockchain technology can assist us in our quest for what may be approximately true in our cultivation. The blockchain acts as a kind of verification mechanism. It exists across several fields, and you likely know it best from cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum.
Yet the blockchain also exists in the realm of the written word. The technology ensures that blockchains prove something that was written has not been altered retroactively. This does not mean that it is true, but it means that it is indelible fact. Witnis has developed a technology that takes us a step along that path.
This means that a person pledges their life — or at least their honor and professional career — that what is stated in the document is what the sender vouches for. On the Witnis blockchain, this means that what was written remains the exact same information, down to the letter, now and for all eternity, as it was the very moment it was recorded. In other words, the sender must stand by it until they revise their stance. But the original ideas will endure on the blockchain for everyone to see.
How one might use Witnis in practice is illustrated by the following example: in 2021, the rumors regarding the LVU campaign began, alleging that Swedish social services were 'kidnapping Muslim children', often children from families with an immigrant background.
The campaign achieved vast international reach, particularly across Arabic-speaking social media. The Psychological Defence Agency described it as an organized influence operation, and in 2023, the government publicly and explicitly countered the claim: Swedish social services do not kidnap Muslim children. The topic remains alive. A scientific study published in 2026 analyzes precisely this narrative that Swedish child welfare allegedly 'kidnaps migrant children', exploring how that story was constructed and disseminated across social platforms.
With a technology like Witnis, social services could immediately step forward and issue a rebuttal to a claim like this directly on a blockchain. This does not mean one can declare it to be held as absolute truth — because that is impossible. But it means that one can place the question of trust front and center. The question of trust is presented directly to the public: who do you believe carries greater truthfulness? The director who affixes their name and signature to declare this false on a blockchain, or those who do not — in this case, the counterpart who spread the rumor?
The former will, with high probability, win majority consensus within Swedish society. But — it must be acknowledged — those groups that already harbored the weakest trust in Swedish authorities, and who were the direct target audience of the falsehood in this instance, are likely more inclined to distrust information on the blockchain as well.
The blockchain cannot, therefore, resolve the cultural dimension of the problem. But perhaps it can win over parts of the group that would otherwise have bought into the fabrication. In any case, it is a step toward what we desire regarding truth.
With today's technology, this is as close to verifiable truth as we can get. The blockchain appears capable of helping us navigate through false information. It is probably not the only tool that will be able to do so, but it is a solid step forward.
Civilization faces monumental challenges when it comes to truth, trust, and evolution. We must do everything in our power to preserve our bildung and coexist with machines. The blockchain could be one of those paths. Witnis is currently laying one of these cornerstones, and that is why I collaborate with them.
Niklas Gerholm
Guest contributorGästskribent — AI-filosof, författare till Syntopism.com
Niklas Gerholm är AI-filosof och författare bakom Syntopism.com, där han utvecklar ett ramverk för kommunikationsparadigm, bildning och approximativ sanning. Han skriver som extern gästskribent; åsikterna i texten är hans egna och representerar inte nödvändigtvis Witnis.
Sources
- Kinesisk studie om outsourcad kognition och kunskapsinhämtning (ScienceDirect, 2025).
- Regeringskansliet (2023). Government taking strong action against disinformation and rumour-spreading campaign.
- Exploring claims in disinformation – The shared story of ‘the Swedish child welfare services’ kidnapping migrant children’ (ScienceDirect, 2026).