Back to blog
AITrustHuman Judgment

Who Do You Trust to Shape Your Thoughts?

On trust, power, and human judgment in the age of AI.

Niklas GerholmGuest contributor2 November 20264 min read
Share this article

Human beings have always depended on trust. We are born without knowledge of the world and learn to understand it through other people. Our parents, teachers, friends, and authorities pass on experiences and knowledge that we use to form our own worldview.

But who decides what we should believe? And why?

Throughout history, power over human thought has shifted alongside the ways we communicate. In early societies, tribal elders passed down knowledge and traditions. With the invention of writing, knowledge could be preserved and spread beyond the reach of the human voice. The Church, monarchies, and other institutions gained increasing influence over what people considered to be true.

The printing press changed the balance of power. Knowledge could reach ever larger audiences, and new institutions emerged. Science, universities, newspapers, and eventually political movements came to shape our understanding of the world. What these transformations have in common is that those who control communication also gain influence over how people think.

Then came the internet.

Suddenly, almost anyone could publish their thoughts and reach a global audience. The power of traditional authorities was challenged. Social media accelerated this transformation even further. Algorithms began determining what information we encounter, often based on what engages us rather than what is true.

And now comes artificial intelligence.

For the first time in history, we can engage in sophisticated conversations with a machine that has access to enormous amounts of human-produced knowledge. It can reason, synthesize information, construct arguments, and answer questions that previously required extensive research. But this raises a fundamental problem; how do we determine whether we can trust its answers?

AI can produce a convincing argument that is completely wrong, and it can also provide correct answers without us understanding why they are correct. The more capable AI becomes, the greater the temptation to hand over our thinking to it. We therefore risk losing something essential: our independent judgment.

Bildung has traditionally been about developing our understanding of ourselves and the world. The ability to place knowledge in context, examine different perspectives, and challenge established beliefs. In the age of AI, this ability becomes more important than ever.

As everyone gains access to the same advanced technology and vast amounts of knowledge, the differences between individuals and organizations will increasingly be determined by their ability to assess, evaluate, and apply that knowledge. We need to understand why we trust a source, what interests may lie behind its claims, and how our own experiences and cultural assumptions influence our conclusions. Those who do not understand why they trust something surrender part of the power over their own thinking to others, and this applies to our fellow human beings, our institutions, and increasingly, our machines.

So the next time you ask AI a question, consider another question: Who are you allowing to shape your thoughts?

Niklas Gerholm

Guest contributor

AI-philosopher

Share this article